Surgeons have significantly criticised two mind surgical procedure operations the place the sufferers went on to die.
Hussien El-Maghraby, a marketing consultant neurosurgeon in Coventry, eliminated a wholesome a part of a mind as an alternative of a tumour throughout one operation.
The 51-year-old was stopped in September from performing two totally different surgical procedures, following a Royal Faculty of Surgeons (RCS) inspection.
Mr El-Maghraby mentioned the Basic Medical Council (GMC) had examined 5 of his operations and dominated no additional motion was wanted.
An knowledgeable who noticed a video of the neurosurgeon’s work on one of many sufferers informed a BBC Inside Out investigation he was “appalled” and described it as “tough surgical procedure”.
Stephen Bridgman, from Redditch, Worcestershire, died after Mr El-Maghraby operated on his benign mind tumour in 2016.
The repercussions of the surgical procedure left Mr Bridgman in a vegetative state, as his mind had been irreparably broken following heavy bleeding.
His widow Mandy Bridgman requested her husband’s medical notes and located a brief video was included exhibiting components of the surgical procedure.
Chris Adams, who was head of neurological surgical procedure on the former Radcliffe Infirmary in Oxford, mentioned: “That is very, very tough surgical procedure. In actual fact I am appalled by it frankly.
“I’ve by no means seen this type of tumour eliminated on this manner – [it has] simply been pulled out in a single piece.
“It is simply fully opposite to how one does neurosurgery.”
“There isn’t any phrases for it. He didn’t have to die,” Mrs Bridgman mentioned.
Two different impartial neurosurgeons spoken to by BBC Inside Out additionally expressed considerations over Mr Bridgman’s surgical procedure.
Mr El-Maghraby, who’s employed by College Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire NHS Belief, mentioned the video had solely lined 20 minutes of the operation that had lasted three hours.
The hospital belief requested for the video to be checked out by its personal impartial knowledgeable, who famous the tumour was eliminated “in a short time” however mentioned it had been indifferent from the cranium in “an inexpensive method”.
4 years earlier, a colleague of Mr El-Maghraby, Munchi Choksey, had raised considerations about some spinal procedures and two operations the place Mr El Maghraby had eliminated mind tissue as an alternative of tumour.
Pathology reviews present a big wholesome chunk of Doreen Dunn’s mind was taken out as an alternative of a benign mind tumour.
A number of days later Mrs Dunn, from Coventry, died.
Mr Choksey considered the scans and mentioned: “It’s a colossal error for any neurosurgeon to make.”
Mrs Dunn’s household weren’t conscious of particulars of the operation till the BBC contacted her daughter Cathy.
“You go to those locations and also you belief that the individuals know what they’re doing,” she mentioned.
“They’re the consultants. So to seek out that one thing like that was not completed correctly… it is a shock.”
‘Simply so indignant’
Mr El-Maghraby, who says he has carried out greater than three,000 operations, informed the BBC Mrs Dunn’s case was one of many 5 examined by the GMC.
He made a proper allegation of bullying towards Mr Choksey.
In September, the RCS was requested to assessment 4 circumstances, together with Mr Bridgman’s.
The belief informed the BBC Mr El-Maghraby ought to chorus from finishing up two particular surgical procedures pending additional coaching and mentorship.
The 2 procedures stopped in October have been advanced spinal operations and mind surgical procedure whereas the affected person is awake.
The assessment recognized no points with routine mind most cancers surgical procedure.
Mrs Bridgman mentioned Mr El-Maghraby “should not be working”.
“I am simply so indignant now that it looks as if lots of people have recognized about this they usually’ve nonetheless let him stick with it.”
You may see this story in full on BBC Inside Out West Midlands at 19:30 GMT on BBC One on Monday 12 March, or through iPlayer for seven days afterwards.
Further reporting by Monica Rimmer