The Scottish Fishermen’s Federation (SFF) has accused ministers of demonstrating “distrust” of their response to a uncommon reef being broken.
In a letter, the SFF mentioned the federal government’s emergency measures undermine confidence in marine safety.
The flame-shell reef in Loch Carron was broken when a scallop dredger dragged its gear proper by means of it.
The incident had been investigated by Scottish Pure Heritage (SNH).
It concluded that the harm was per scallop dredging and that there was a “viable” likelihood of restoration.
On Friday, Atmosphere Secretary Roseanna Cunningham gave Loch Carron emergency safety by designating 16 sq. kilometres of it a Marine Protected Space (MPA).
However in a letter to Ms Cunningham and Rural Affairs Secretary Fergus Ewing, the federation’s chief government, Bertie Armstrong, raised concern concerning the course of.
He mentioned 5 comparable reefs have been already closed to fishing and that MPAs have been designed to guard “examples” of uncommon sea options, not all of them.
He added that the transfer was a “de facto assertion of distrust” within the technique of Marine Protected Areas.
The letter continued: “You’ll know that this logical, sequential, evidence-based endeavour is one which we, as straight affected stakeholders, haven’t solely participated in however straight promoted on the worldwide stage as an exemplar for others, balancing effectively the related Scottish authorities insurance policies of wholesome and productive seas.
“Stepping exterior the method undermines confidence in a balanced authorities method to MPAs.”
On Friday, the setting secretary mentioned the MPA was an emergency measure and that steps can be taken to make it everlasting.
Roseanna Cunningham confirmed that the harm was per scallop dredging however that there was a “viable prospect of restoration” for the reef.
The marketing campaign group Open Seas mentioned the transfer was “too little, too late” and that MPAs must be imposed on much more reefs.